Monica Cardona
Member
What are the main benefits and drawbacks of choosing an above-ground pool over an in-ground one?
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Is an Above Ground Pool Worth the Investment?
- Thread starter Monica Cardona
- Start date
Nia Thompson
New member
We looked at both when planning our pool, and it really came down to what fit our space and budget. Above-ground pools definitely have some upsides, especially if you’re trying to keep costs under control.What are the main benefits and drawbacks of choosing an above-ground pool over an in-ground one?
They’re way cheaper to install, no excavation, no heavy equipment, and usually a much faster setup. If you ever need to move or just want the option to take it down, that flexibility’s nice to have. Maintenance is about the same either way, but with above-ground, it’s often easier to spot leaks or issues since everything’s visible.
That said, they don’t blend into the yard as smoothly. We tried to dress ours up with a deck and landscaping, but it still doesn’t have that built-in look. They also tend to have more limits when it comes to size and shape, most are round or oval, and you won’t get the same depth options.
In-ground pools definitely win on aesthetics and long-term value. They become part of the property in a way an above-ground one usually doesn’t. But the price jump is big, and once it’s in, that’s it, there’s no moving it later.
If budget’s tight or you're not planning to stay in the house long term, above-ground can be a smart call. But if you want something more permanent and customized, and you’re willing to spend more up front, in-ground is hard to beat.
David Wilson
Member
Honestly, it comes down to what you need and how long you plan to stay put. Above-ground pools are much easier on the wallet, and you can get them up and running in just a few days without dealing with heavy equipment or long permits. They’re also simple to take care of and, if needed, can even be taken apart later or replaced without a huge cost.
On the other hand, in-ground pools look more polished and add solid value to your home. They can be shaped and finished any way you like, but that freedom comes with a big price tag and a permanent commitment.
If you’re after something fun, affordable, and flexible, an above-ground pool makes sense.
On the other hand, in-ground pools look more polished and add solid value to your home. They can be shaped and finished any way you like, but that freedom comes with a big price tag and a permanent commitment.
If you’re after something fun, affordable, and flexible, an above-ground pool makes sense.
Nathan Parker
Member
We’ve had our above-ground pool for two summers now, and I’d say it’s been worth it. The setup was quick, and upkeep’s been simple. I toss in Aquadoc’s clarifier once a week, and the water stays clear. It might not look as fancy as an in-ground one, but for what we paid and how easy it is to manage, it’s been a solid choice.