Choosing Between Resin and Steel Pool Kits — Which Holds Up Better Long Term?

[Sophia Henry]

I’m looking at a few different above ground pool kits and noticed some are made with resin frames while others use steel. The price difference isn’t huge, but I’ve heard mixed things about how each holds up over time. If you’ve owned or installed either type, how did it hold up after a few seasons? Any issues with rust, warping, or general wear? Just trying to figure out which is the better option before I commit.

 

[Amber Chase]

I’m looking at a few different above ground pool kits and noticed some are made with resin frames while others use steel. The price difference isn’t huge, but I’ve heard mixed things about how each holds up over time. If you’ve owned or installed either type, how did it hold up after a few seasons? Any issues with rust, warping, or general wear? Just trying to figure out which is the better option before I commit.

I’ve owned both types over the years, and each has its pros depending on your setup and climate.

Resin frames are a solid choice if you live somewhere humid or near the coast. They don’t rust, which is a huge plus, and they tend to keep their appearance over time. Ours made it through three hot summers with no signs of wear, no cracks, no fading. They also handle splashes from the pool chemicals without any trouble, which is nice when kids are going in and out all day.

Steel frames do feel sturdier when you’re setting things up, and they work well for bigger pools. But they do need more attention. We had one steel-walled pool that started showing some rust by the end of the second season, mostly near the fittings and spots where water collected. Not a deal-breaker, but it does mean more upkeep.

If you want something that stays looking clean and doesn’t need much fuss, I’d lean toward resin. But if you’re in a drier spot and don’t mind checking things more often, steel can still last a good while.

Hope that helps while you’re deciding, feel free to ask if you’re comparing specific kits.

 

[Richard Thomas]

I’m looking at a few different above ground pool kits and noticed some are made with resin frames while others use steel. The price difference isn’t huge, but I’ve heard mixed things about how each holds up over time. If you’ve owned or installed either type, how did it hold up after a few seasons? Any issues with rust, warping, or general wear? Just trying to figure out which is the better option before I commit.

I’ve had both types, and here’s what I found. Resin frames are generally more durable and resistant to rust, which is a big plus in the long run. They also tend to hold up better in harsh weather, like extreme heat or cold. I had one for a few seasons and didn’t have any issues with warping or wear.

On the other hand, steel frames are usually cheaper, but they can start to rust over time, especially if you’re in an area with a lot of moisture. I had a steel-framed pool that started showing signs of rust after a couple of years, even though I took care of it.

If you’re looking for long-term durability and less maintenance, I’d go with a resin frame. It might cost a little more upfront, but it’ll likely save you hassle in the long run.

 

[Monica Cardona]

I’m looking at a few different above ground pool kits and noticed some are made with resin frames while others use steel. The price difference isn’t huge, but I’ve heard mixed things about how each holds up over time. If you’ve owned or installed either type, how did it hold up after a few seasons? Any issues with rust, warping, or general wear? Just trying to figure out which is the better option before I commit.

Resin frames are rust-resistant and low-maintenance, making them great for long-term use, especially in humid or salty environments. They tend to last longer without issues like rust or warping. Steel frames are stronger and offer more support but are prone to rust if not properly maintained. If you want less maintenance, resin is the way to go, but if strength is a priority and you're okay with occasional upkeep, steel could be a good option.

 

[Andrew Coleman]

I’ve gone back and forth between the two over the years, and what stood out for me was how each one “ages.” The resin frame I had didn’t really change much season to season, no rust spots, no weird marks, and it didn’t fade even though the pool got a ton of afternoon sun. The steel one felt a bit beefier at first, but the corners and hardware started showing rust quicker than I expected, especially after a rainy stretch.

If you’re hoping for something that stays looking the same without babysitting it, resin held up better for me long term. Steel can absolutely work, but it’s the type you want to keep an eye on so little rust patches don’t turn into bigger problems later.