Muriatic Acid for Closing a 25,000-Gallon Gunite Pool With High Alkalinity
Closing a 25,000-gallon gunite pool when alkalinity is high takes more muriatic acid than most guides assume, and skipping this step correctly sets you up for a rough spring opening. This post walks through exact doses, the right order of additions, and what happens if you close at the wrong pH.

Muriatic Acid for Closing a 25,000-Gallon Gunite Pool With High Alkalinity
Closing a pool is satisfying right up until you test the water and realize your alkalinity is sitting at 180 or 200 ppm when it needs to be under 100. Now you have a chemistry problem to solve before you can button everything up for winter, and the pressure to just cover the pool and deal with it in spring is real. Do not give in to that pressure, especially with a gunite pool where high alkalinity causes scale buildup that can ruin a plaster surface over a long off-season.
For a 25,000-gallon gunite pool with high alkalinity, you need to add muriatic acid in stages before closing. The exact amount depends on how far you need to drop both alkalinity and pH, but as a working benchmark: lowering alkalinity by 10 ppm in a 25,000-gallon pool requires roughly 26 oz (about 1.6 pints) of 31.45% muriatic acid per treatment pass. For a severe case, say alkalinity at 200 ppm dropping to 90 ppm, you are looking at a total of 15 to 18 pints of acid spread across multiple days. This article explains why that multi-pass approach is necessary, walks through the full dose math, and covers the right order to adjust your water before covering the pool.
Why High Alkalinity Is a Bigger Problem at Closing Than Mid-Season
During swimming season, you have the pump running daily and you can re-dose and retest frequently. At closing, the water under a solid or safety cover is largely static for four to six months. High alkalinity, anything above 120 ppm, pushes pH up continuously over the off-season. By the time you open in spring, pH can easily climb above 8.0, dropping your chlorine effectiveness to near zero and causing calcium carbonate to precipitate out of solution and form scale on the plaster, tile, and pool equipment. For a gunite pool, that scale is particularly costly because removing it often means acid washing or even replastering. Getting alkalinity into the 80 to 100 ppm range before closing, and pH into the 7.2 to 7.4 range, is the single most protective thing you can do for the surface over winter.
It is also worth understanding why you cannot just dump a large amount of acid in at once. As explained in the guide on Total Alkalinity vs pH: Fix TA First, Here’s Why, alkalinity acts as a buffer against pH change. When both are high, lowering alkalinity actually requires you to temporarily tank your pH, then aerate to bring pH back up without raising alkalinity. That means a single-day fix is not realistic when you are starting 80 or 100 ppm above target.
The Dose Math for a 25,000-Gallon Pool
Standard pool chemistry reference tells us that 1 quart (32 oz) of 31.45% muriatic acid lowers total alkalinity by approximately 10 ppm in 10,000 gallons of water. Scaling to 25,000 gallons means 1 quart drops alkalinity by only 4 ppm, so to drop 10 ppm you need about 2.5 quarts (80 oz) per 10 ppm at this volume. Some published resources use a slightly more conservative figure of 26 oz per 10 ppm at 25,000 gallons when accounting for typical acid concentration variation; that is the safer number to use in practice.
Here is a worked example. Say your pool tests at:
- Total alkalinity: 190 ppm (target: 90 ppm, so a 100 ppm drop needed)
- pH: 7.9 (target: 7.2 to 7.4 for closing)
To drop 100 ppm of alkalinity, divide 100 by 10, then multiply by 26 oz: that gives you 260 oz, or about 16 pints of muriatic acid total. You do not add all of this at once. Add 3 to 4 pints per pass, pour it slowly in front of a return jet while the pump runs, then let the water circulate for at least two hours before retesting. After each pass your pH will drop sharply (often below 7.0) while alkalinity falls more slowly. That is normal and expected. Turn off the pump and run an aerator, waterfall, or just let the fountains run to off-gas CO2 and bring pH back up toward 7.2 before the next acid pass. Each full cycle of acid plus aeration takes 12 to 24 hours, so plan on three to five days to bring a severely high alkalinity pool into range before closing.
Dose Reference Table for Common Starting Points
| Starting Alkalinity (ppm) | Target Alkalinity (ppm) | ppm Drop Needed | Total Acid Required (oz) | Total Acid Required (pints) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 120 | 90 | 30 | 78 | ~5 |
| 150 | 90 | 60 | 156 | ~10 |
| 180 | 90 | 90 | 234 | ~15 |
| 200 | 90 | 110 | 286 | ~18 |
| 220 | 90 | 130 | 338 | ~21 |
These figures assume 31.45% concentration muriatic acid, the standard pool-grade strength sold at most hardware and pool supply stores. If your acid is labeled at a lower concentration (28% or 20%), you will need proportionally more. Divide the ounce figure by the decimal concentration: for 20% acid at the 180 ppm starting point, divide 234 by 0.635 to get roughly 368 oz, or about 23 pints.
Step-by-Step Closing Process for a High-Alkalinity Gunite Pool
- Step 1: Test thoroughly. Test total alkalinity, pH, free chlorine, calcium hardness, and CYA at least two days before your intended closing date. You need time to fix chemistry before you can close.
- Step 2: Start the alkalinity reduction process. Add 3 to 4 pints of muriatic acid in front of a return jet with the pump running. Broadcast it across the deep end if you are adding a large dose. Never pour acid into a skimmer.
- Step 3: Circulate, then aerate. Run the pump for two hours after each acid addition. Then switch to aerating (waterfalls, fountains, or return jets aimed to break the surface) for 8 to 12 hours to let pH recover before the next dose.
- Step 4: Retest and repeat. Retest alkalinity and pH before each additional acid pass. Keep going until alkalinity is at 80 to 100 ppm and pH is at 7.2 to 7.4.
- Step 5: Adjust calcium hardness if needed. Gunite pools should close at 200 to 250 ppm calcium hardness. If yours is low, add calcium chloride after your pH is stable. Adding it to already-acidic water will cause it to drop cleanly without clouding.
- Step 6: Shock the pool. Add a closing dose of chlorine shock (10 ppm or more for a gunite pool) with the pump running at night, 24 to 48 hours after the last acid addition.
- Step 7: Add a winterizing algaecide. Follow with a polyquat 60 algaecide the same evening as the shock or the following morning. AquaDoc makes a winterizing algaecide that pool owners use at this exact stage as a last-line defense against algae blooms under a closed cover.
- Step 8: Lower the water level and cover. Drop water below the skimmer, blow out and plug the lines, and install the cover only after chemistry is fully dialed in.
Common Mistakes That Undermine All Your Work
- Adding too much acid at once: More than 4 pints per dose in a 25,000-gallon pool at one time can send pH crashing below 6.8, which risks etching gunite plaster faster than scale would have. Slow and steady wins here.
- Skipping aeration between passes: Without aeration, pH stays depressed and alkalinity does not fall as efficiently. The aeration step is not optional; it is mechanically how the TA reduction process works.
- Closing too soon after acid addition: If you cover the pool while pH is still at 6.9 or 7.0, you are essentially marinating your plaster in acidic water for months. Wait until pH has stabilized at 7.2 to 7.4 before closing.
- Ignoring calcium hardness: High alkalinity often comes paired with high calcium hardness. If you over-correct alkalinity without checking calcium, you can inadvertently shift the Langelier Saturation Index (LSI) far into the negative range, which is just as damaging to plaster as high scale-forming water.
- Pouring acid directly against the plaster wall: Always pour into the deepest part of the water or directly in front of a return jet. Concentrated acid sitting on plaster for even a few seconds can etch or discolor the surface.
What to Expect at Spring Opening
If you close with alkalinity at 90 ppm and pH at 7.2 to 7.4, expect to open in spring with pH somewhere around 7.4 to 7.8 depending on your climate, cover type, and how much CO2 the water picked up over winter. That is a quick correction at opening, not a multi-day chemistry project. Alkalinity will typically be close to where you left it, maybe 10 to 15 ppm higher if you had any rain intrusion under the cover. If you notice a water level change that seems larger than normal evaporation accounts for, check out the guide on Pool Losing Water: Evaporation or a Leak? Here’s How to Know before writing it off. A leak that runs all winter under a cover can throw off every chemical balance you worked to set at closing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much muriatic acid do I add to a 25,000-gallon pool to lower alkalinity?
To drop total alkalinity by 10 ppm in a 25,000-gallon pool, add approximately 26 oz (about 1.6 pints) of 31.45% muriatic acid per treatment pass. If your alkalinity is 200 ppm and you need to reach 90 ppm, that is a 110 ppm drop, requiring roughly 18 pints of acid added in stages over several days with aeration in between each pass.
What pH should I target when closing a gunite pool for winter?
Target a pH of 7.2 to 7.4 when closing a gunite pool. This is slightly lower than the normal swimming range because pH tends to drift upward over winter. Landing in the 7.4 to 7.6 range by spring is far better than opening to a pH above 8.0, which causes scale and kills chlorine effectiveness.
What alkalinity level should a gunite pool be at for winter closing?
Target 80 to 100 ppm for total alkalinity at closing. Gunite plaster is vulnerable to both high-pH scale formation and low-pH etching, so hitting that range before you cover the pool protects the surface through the off-season without overcorrecting into corrosive territory.
Can I add muriatic acid and then close the pool the same day?
No. Add muriatic acid at least 24 to 48 hours before closing, with the pump running throughout. The acid needs to circulate fully, aeration needs time to bring pH back up, and both pH and alkalinity need to stabilize before you add winterizing chemicals and cover the pool.
What happens if I close a pool with alkalinity that is too high?
High alkalinity going into winter causes calcium carbonate scale to form on the plaster, tile, and equipment as temperatures fluctuate. It also keeps pH elevated, which drops chlorine effectiveness sharply. By spring you can open to a cloudy, lightly algae-tinted pool with surface scaling that requires significant effort to fix.
The bottom line: a 25,000-gallon gunite pool starting above 150 ppm alkalinity will need 10 to 18 pints of muriatic acid applied in multiple passes over several days to close safely. Do the work before you put the cover on and your spring opening will take an hour instead of a week.
